How far is a Local Pie pizza from the Palmetto Bluff gate? Until this year the nearest answer was Old Town Bluffton or the island. Now Google Maps puts it at about 2.9 miles and roughly five minutes, driving out SC-46 and Old Palmetto Bluff Road to Compass Commons at New Riverside Village. From 1 Village Park Square, deeper inside the community, the same lookup estimates 7.0 miles and about 14 minutes.
Three Hilton Head names opened there over the course of 2026: Local Pie, Frosty Frog Cafe and Cafe Al Dente. Each is a familiar island restaurant opening a second or third door on the mainland, and together they make the SC 46 roundabout the closest place to get an island-style casual dinner without crossing the bridge.
The island names, at mainland addresses
Here is what has opened at and around Compass Commons, and when. The development sits at the corner of New Riverside Road and SC 46, just off the roundabout where SC 170, SC 46 and New Riverside Road meet.
| Business | Address | Island or regional roots | Opened |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local Pie | 135 Parkside Commons | Hilton Head, 2015 | Mid-April 2026 |
| Frosty Frog Cafe | 147 Parkside Commons | Hilton Head | Open by July 2026 |
| Cafe Al Dente | 303 Parkside Commons, Suite 103 | Coligny Plaza, Hilton Head | Soft opening Oct. 1, 2026 |
| Nom Nom Poke Shop | 267 Parkside Commons, Suite 102 | Savannah | November 2025 |
| Grind Coffee Roasters | 349 Hope Pond Way, Unit 104 | Lowcountry roaster | Open now |
| New York Butcher Shoppe | 375 Hope Pond Way, Unit 101 | Regional butcher | Open now |
| Eggs Up Grill | New Riverside Village | Regional breakfast chain | May 2024 |
| Flatbread Grill & Bar | New Riverside Village | Local | March 2025 |
Compass Commons also has Bluffton Ice Cream, Pet Wants, STMT Boutique and Burke's Pharmacy. All four were open before the 2026 restaurant openings, according to the Island Packet.
Why the island brands landed here
The tenant mix was planned. Lee Lucier, chief operating officer of The Richardson Group, which oversees the development, told the Island Packet that Compass Commons was designed to showcase locally rooted businesses, much like the mix at Coligny Plaza on Hilton Head Island. The project has four buildings with more than 16,000 square feet in total, and it has been in the works since 2020.
That Coligny comparison explains the lineup. Cafe Al Dente came straight from Coligny Plaza. Local Pie and Frosty Frog are island names too. A shopping center trying to recreate Coligny's mix on SC 46 would recruit exactly these businesses.
It also took longer than planned. In January 2026, the Island Packet reported that Local Pie expected to open by mid-February, with Frosty Frog and Cafe Al Dente following by early April. Local Pie opened in mid-April. Frosty Frog was open by early July. Cafe Al Dente didn't open until October. The full set has only been in place for about five weeks, so the cluster is new even to people who drive past it every day.
The courtyard between the pizza ovens and the frozen drinks
Local Pie's New Riverside location is its third, after the original on Hilton Head, which opened in 2015, and the Old Town Bluffton location that followed two years later. Eat It & Like It reported that the new space is a bit smaller than the island location and a bit larger than Old Town, with seating for about 100 including the outdoor tables. It has two ovens running and two very large televisions over the bar.
The outdoor tables sit between Local Pie and Frosty Frog, its next-door neighbor. When Local Pie opened in April, Eat It & Like It's Jesse Blanco described the space this way:
"I suspect the smallish courtyard to eventually be among the more lively spots in the New Riverside area, particularly in Spring and Fall when the weather cooperates."
When he wrote that, Frosty Frog was still under construction. Eat It & Like It's July roundup later reported that "the lonnnnnng awaited Frosty Frog" was open at New Riverside. November is the first fall with both businesses open on either side of that courtyard.
Frosty Frog's events calendar is fairly quiet for the rest of the year. After Halloween, the next event it lists is a New Year's Eve event on Thursday, Dec. 31.
Cafe Al Dente, the newest arrival
Cafe Al Dente is a scratch-made Italian restaurant that started in Oyster Bay, New York. Eat It & Like It reported that Damien and Yakshi Carlino brought it to Coligny Plaza in February 2024. The Bluffton location held its soft opening Oct. 1, 2026, at 303 Parkside Commons, Suite 103. Earlier reporting gave the address as 307 Parkside Commons. The October sources list 303.
One practical detail matters for dinner plans. Cafe Al Dente opened as BYOB while it waited for final liquor license approval. A public notice shows that DVVY Group LLC, doing business as Cafe Al Dente, applied on Oct. 4 for an on-premises beer, wine and liquor license, with objections due by Oct. 20. Call ahead to ask whether to bring a bottle.
One stop for dinner and the errands around it
Grouping these businesses together cuts down on separate trips. On the Hope Pond Way side of New Riverside Village, Grind Coffee Roasters takes online orders at Unit 104, and New York Butcher Shoppe is open at Unit 101. Burke's Pharmacy and Pet Wants are in Compass Commons itself.
That means a 2.9-mile drive from the Palmetto Bluff gate can cover coffee, a butcher, a pharmacy refill, pet supplies, poke, pizza and Italian in one place. In April, Eat It & Like It also mentioned a Chipotle and a CVS Pharmacy as coming to the area. Neither has an address or opening date yet. The Chipotle proposal reported elsewhere is for May River Crossing, off Okatie Highway, not this corner.
The roundabout itself may change
The traffic circle that makes Compass Commons easy to reach is being studied. In March 2026, the Island Packet reported on a study proposal to replace the SC 170 and SC 46 traffic circle with a signal and to add a pedestrian bridge. The bridge would connect New Riverside Barn Park to a multi-use path toward Sun City Boulevard. It is a study, not a construction notice, and it has no work date. For now the drive from the gate stays the same.
The park on the other side of that circle has its own calendar. The Town of Bluffton lists the All Nashville Roadshow on the Barn at New Riverside Event Lawn, 38 Red Barn Drive, on Sunday, Nov. 22, from 3 to 6 p.m. It ends early enough for dinner afterward. Compass Commons is just off that same roundabout, and Local Pie's opening hours ran from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily.
If you're getting to know the stretch of SC 46 between Palmetto Bluff and the New Riverside roundabout, whether you live here now or are thinking about it, Stefany Cerame can share how this new cluster of shops and restaurants fits into everyday life around the Bluffton communities she covers. Schedule a Consultation when you're ready to talk it through.